You heard it once, hours ago — a jingle in a lift, a chorus from a shop doorway — and now it is still playing in your head at 11 p.m., when you would very much like it to stop. Psychologists call this involuntary musical imagery. Everyone else calls it an earworm, and it is one of the most common things a mind does without being asked.
How common? In a 2012 survey of 12,519 Finnish internet users, L. A. Liikkanen found 89.2% experienced involuntary music at least once a week. A 2010 diary study by Philip Beaman and Tim Williams at the University of Reading followed 12 volunteers for four weeks: their earworms lasted about 27 minutes on average, only about a third were unpleasant, and few came back the same day. This piece is based on published research like that — not on experiments I ran myself.
An earworm is a fragment of music — usually 15 to 30 seconds long — that your brain replays without your permission. Researchers call it involuntary musical imagery: the spontaneous recall of a tune, with no conscious effort involved. The leading explanation involves the phonological loop, the part of working memory that holds sounds for a second or two while you rehearse them — the same system that holds a phone number just long enough to dial it. A catchy phrase slips into that loop and the rehearsal system keeps refreshing it. The loop is doing its normal job; it has simply been handed the wrong material. That is also why earworms strike when your mind has spare capacity — a routine commute, a shower, a dull meeting — rather than when you are concentrating hard. The same involuntary recall shows up with smells — see the Proust effect.
For years the honest answer was that nobody knew. Then a team led by Kelly Jakubowski, a music psychologist now at Durham University, set out to answer it properly. Between 2010 and 2013, about 3,000 people named the tunes that most often got stuck in their heads. The three most-named were Lady Gaga's “Bad Romance”, Kylie Minogue's “Can't Get You Out Of My Head” and Journey's “Don't Stop Believin'”. They then matched 100 frequently named earworm tunes with similar songs that had never been named, comparing the two groups across 83 features of the melody. The sticky songs shared a pattern: a familiar overall melodic shape (the APA pointed to “Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star” as an example), faster tempos, and less common interval patterns — unexpected leaps, or more repeated notes than typical pop. In short, a tune gets stuck when it is easy enough to follow and just surprising enough to hold your attention. “Our findings show that you can, to some extent, predict which songs are going to get stuck in people's heads,” Jakubowski said in the APA's release on the study — which is also why advertisers spend so much on jingles.
Here is the fun part — and the strangest genuine finding in this whole field. In 2015, researchers at the University of Reading ran an experiment with 98 volunteers. Each person heard catchy songs — Maroon 5's “Payphone” and David Guetta's “Play Hard” among them — then was asked not to think about them for three minutes, pressing a key every time the tune popped back into their head. Some chewed gum; others did nothing, or tapped a finger as a control. Chewing gum cut the replay by about a third; finger-tapping did not match it. The theory: chewing occupies the jaw and the subvocal rehearsal system — the silent, internal singing that keeps a tune alive — so the loop cannot refresh itself as easily. It is a modest effect, measured over minutes in a lab with songs the researchers chose — not a cure for a tune that has bugged you all day. But it is real, and it is why “chew gum” tops nearly every evidence-based list of earworm remedies.
Three approaches have the best experimental support. First, listen to the whole song, start to finish. One explanation researchers propose is the Zeigarnik effect: the brain holds on to unfinished business, and a half-remembered chorus is unfinished business. Hearing the song through may give it the closure the loop is waiting for. Second, give your working memory a moderately difficult job — anagrams, a puzzle, a crossword. A 2013 study by Hyman and colleagues found engaging tasks interrupt the loop; the task must be absorbing enough to claim the rehearsal system, but not so hard your mind wanders back to the tune. Third, chew gum, per the Reading experiment above. What does not help is ordering yourself not to think about it: the harder you push a thought away, the more your brain keeps checking whether it is gone, which keeps it front and centre. If an earworm lasts more than a day, or comes with other symptoms, that is a different matter — persistent musical imagery can occasionally be linked to medical conditions, so mention it to a doctor. The ordinary kind usually burns itself out within the hour. And if you are curious how much of this mental machinery can actually be trained, see whether brain-training apps work — the evidence there is more sobering than the marketing suggests.
An earworm is not your brain malfunctioning. It is your memory system doing what it evolved to do — rehearsing patterns and finishing unfinished sequences. The same machinery that keeps a chorus looping is the machinery that lets you remember a route, a recipe, or a friend's voice. A stuck song is annoying, but it is also a small, audible reminder that your mind is always working, even when you did not ask it to.
Related on Poptani Labs: Do brain-training apps work? What the evidence actually says, The Proust effect: why one smell can time-travel you back, Decision fatigue: why judges said no before lunch. More in this category: The Human Operating System.
Sources: Why Songs Get Stuck in Your Head (Something Navy), Earworm — Wikipedia, Why Songs Get Stuck in Your Head: Inside an Auditory Memory Loop (Oddly Clear), The Science Behind Earworms (Science Array)